Showing posts with label homeopathy homoeopathy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label homeopathy homoeopathy. Show all posts

Saturday, 18 February 2017

A Victory for Common-Sense


A long long time ago, UK veterinary surgeon Phil Hyde came across the website of fellow UK veterinary surgeon, Roger Meacock. What he found there depressed him.

On his website, Mr Meacock starts by pointing out he is a ‘fully qualified veterinary surgeon who has established an international reputation for treating animals using a wide range of cutting-edge healing technologies and products.’ After that things start to go steadily down-hill as we discover the ‘cutting-edge healing technologies and products’ on sale are not what you might think and that, although Mr Meacock obviously believes passionately in them, some of his ideas are a little silly. In fact, this web site seems to be something of a Grand Central Station of Silly, where there is an uncritical acceptance of a wide range of nonscience-based concepts, regardless of scientific merit, proper evidence or plain common-sense.

For instance Mr Meacock tells us the Russians can change DNA using only words and language, to restore group consciousness and clairvoyance. Readers are advised that ten drops of ‘Aerobic Oxygen’ in a glass of water will increase its oxygen levels by over 400% and drinking it will boost the oxygen concentration of animals’ blood (clearly drinking oxygen is much more efficient than breathing it). Then there is Quinton Marine Plasma, which harnesses ‘the [unspecified] healing power of seawater’ and the Silent Healing CD, a recording of (you guessed it) complete silence, apparently useful for ‘space clearing and for group healing.’

The ‘Russian Healing Blanket’ we are told, in a glorious riot of technobabble, is a ‘new informo-bioenergetic therapeutic tool which uses the patient's own reflected infra-red and extra-high frequency emissions... [and] more evenly distributes the surface electrical charge density [of the body], thus providing a reservoir of energy that is drawn into the body through deficient biologically active points... of the body surface to rebalance the meridians and body energy systems.’

Phil felt strongly these sorts of evidence-free and patently ridiculous claims might be both damaging the reputation of the profession and, more importantly, harmful to animals. He initially brought his concerns to the attention of prospective candidates for positions in the council of the of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons (RCVS - the governing body for the UK profession) during an election debate at the forum Vetsurgeon.org in 2013. His pleas fell on deaf ears.

Shortly afterwards he lodged a formal complaint about Mr Meacock and his website with the RCVS’s Preliminary Investigation Committee (PIC). The complaint was first made in December 2014 and I was pleased to be asked at that time to help. Phil received a copy of Mr Meacock’s response to the complaint from the RCVS, which, though heavy on personal attack, was extremely light on the actual evidence Phil had asked for. Instead of arguing his case, Mr Meacock instead brought a charge against Phil himself, for bullying, a complaint which was later dismissed by the RCVS.

The RCVS is no different from any other large bureaucracy and has a lot on its plate. Inevitably there were many false starts and adjournments. Feeling he was getting nowhere Phil contacted Arlo Guthrie, the editor of www.Vetsurgeon.org, one of the largest and most active veterinary forums in the UK, for advice.

Arlo’s first instinct was to get together a group of like minded veterinary surgeons to offer advice and to widen the field to make the strength of feeling among the profession clearer to the RCVS. This group initially got together in August 2015 and thus was born the Campaign for Rational Veterinary Medicine (CfRVM), with the aim of responding to the false claims of veterinary alternative practitioners in the media, to publicise the real risks to animal welfare and the ethical concerns over veterinary homeopathy and to get this message across to the RCVS in order to convince the authorities this wasn’t a lone voice, but a united front. This was done in the form of direct submissions and a petition in support of reforming the (to date) laissez faire attitude of the RCVS.

Finally, nearly 2 years after the initial complaint, Mr Meacock was presented, by the RCVS, with a list of charges and advised the accusation was one of ‘conduct disgraceful in a professional respect’ and that he was to face ‘six charges relating to matters asserted on his website which the College alleged were misleading and/or inaccurate to the point of bringing the veterinary profession into disrepute’.[1] The hearing date was set for Tuesday 18 October 2016. Phil and other members of the CfRVM headed for London.

The day of the hearing involved a lot of waiting around in court where more knitting than legal debate took place. But finally an announcement was made. The Disciplinary Committee hearing into Roger Sidney Meacock MRCVS was being adjourned as he had voluntarily agreed to ‘amend his website in order to make it compliant with his professional responsibilities’. While this was not entirely what had been expected, it was nevertheless a victory, and a step forward for professional standards in the UK veterinary profession.

Mr Meacock and the far-fetched claims on his website were the catalyst that brought the members of the Campaign for Rational Veterinary Medicine together, and our work continues. We care about the rational and scientific basis for the UK veterinary profession and will continue to question the irrational ideas and treatments promoted by a small but vocal section of the profession to the detriment of our patients. Only with a real world foundation for the treatments we use and the advice we give can we be certain the animals which trust us to do our best for them are treated fairly and with respect and their owners and caregivers are not misled into believing certain treatments are effective when they are most certainly not.

So thanks, Roger, we owe it all to you.

References: 

1] Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons RCVS (2016) Disciplinary hearing for Staffordshire-based vet adjourned following undertakings [Online]. Available at http://www.rcvs.org.uk/news-and-events/news/disciplinary-hearing-for-derbyshire-based-vet-adjourned/ (Accessed 16 February 2017).

Monday, 11 January 2016

Homeopaths' bogus arguments - No. 12

Homeopathy is a different way of knowing and works perfectly well within its own frame of reference – it cannot be judged by science.

This ‘everything is subjective’ line is a well worn trope heard from many practitioners of CAVM – how can science ‘prove itself’, much less disprove anything which operates oustide its purview? Such commentators though want it both ways as we will see.

The point hinges on the very philosophy of science itself and disingenuous homeopaths as well as well-meaning but naïve scientists will suggest that any scientific argument against homeopathy is, at its root, prejudice. Homeopathy, it is claimed, is merely one of many ways of looking at the world and understanding it. As such, although different from science, it is deserving of equal respect. Good scientists, critics say, recognise this and should always have doubt. Well, that last point is certainly true, but it doesn’t mean doubt can be filled in with any old far-fetched nonsense which springs to mind.

To be clear, the core philosophy of science has little to do with the way medical trials are conducted or the usefulness evidence-based medicine. Certainly, medicine employs scientific tools – the double blind placebo controlled trial, confidence intervals, metanalyses and so forth but medicine (and by extension EBM) is no more a science than engineering is, both use science but that does not make them science; they are technologies.

One of the best illustrations of scientific principles is simply if something is going to claim scientific credentials then those credentials must be able to be tested by science. That’s it really, nothing more – 'Put up or shut up' in other words. Science isn't even about finding answers, being far more concerned with asking questions.

Philosophers of a post-modern bent (and possibly a few who like to sound clever!) will argue science is just 'another way of knowing' and that all healing (and other) modalities are equal but different. While this makes for interesting debate it is meaningless in practical terms in the real world. We know much of how the universe works. Consequently we know if a culture believes it is possible for humans to fly unaided while it might be polite of us not to directly contradict or otherwise disrespect members of that particular culture, even a homeopath would be ill advised to take politeness so far as to step out of a high window on their say-so. You can't have one set of facts, or truths for one group and a different set for another.

Critics are regularly castigated by its adherents for describing homeopathy as unscientific. Quite the opposite we are told, loudly and with vigour, homeopathy does indeed work by scientific principles (inevitably quantum physics as a rule), non-homeopaths are just too feeble-minded to see it. Yet, when the paucity of their ‘scientific’ evidence is pointed out to them, instead of doing the scientific thing by upping the ante and performing better tests homeopaths instead accuse critics of prejudice and bigotry while at the same time doing a volte face and hiding behind the skirts of New-Age philosophising. From this refuge they will claim they’ve changed their mind and actually homeopathy can't be tested by science afterall (that is until the next poorly performed trial comes along which claims even the smallest of effects from homeopathy, at which point all the mental gymnastics and philosophical navel-gazing get quietly shelved!). This really is wanting to have one’s cake and eat it, but that isn't how science works.

Homeopathy craves all the kudos and credibility science brings but will not accept the scientific process and the discipline that comes with it – mainly the discipline of discarding cherished beliefs in the face of contradictory evidence. It is homeopaths who are attempting to prove homeopathy by science, not scientists. If they were content to present themselves as practitioners of a mystic, unexplainable and untestable philosophy this whole debate would have a very different tone.

Thursday, 7 January 2016

Homeopaths' bogus arguments - No. 11

"But we don't even know why mainstream drugs work, why pick on homeopathy - what about anaesthetics!"

This particular argument runs along the lines that since, allegedly, we don’t know how many conventional drugs work we should basically cut homeopathy some slack and give it the benefit of the doubt. A favourite example is anaesthetics with claims that we have no idea how they work and no information as to their safety or cost-effectiveness, the implication being that if anaesthetics (which obviously do work) have no known mechanism of action then homeopathy also must work even though it also has no known mechanism of action.

This is simply another tu quoque argument – flawed and designed to mislead. There are several problems with it, not least of which is that even if we really did have no idea how pharmaceutical drugs worked it still wouldn't mean it was ok to go on using homeopathy. We don't have to worry about that though because not only is this argument illogical, it is based on a falsehood, presumably put about in the hope that readers won’t bother to check the far-fetched claims being made in the defence of homeopathy.

In fact we have a very good idea of how pharmaceuticals work, including anaesthetics. Take Alfaxan (alfaxalone) for example, a popular veterinary anaesthetic agent. Alfaxalone binds to specific binding sites on the gamma animo butyric acid (GABA) sub-type A receptors on the cells of the Central Nervous System. GABA is a major inhibitory neurotransmitter. When GABA binds to the GABA-A receptors this results in opening of chloride channels into the cells and an influx of chloride ions, resulting in hyperpolarisation of the cells and inhibition of neural impulse transmission. Alfaxalone enhances the effects of GABA at the GABA-A receptors, so causing greater inhibition of neural impulse transmission and, thereby, unconsciousness. This information, along with safety and cost data is widely available in textbooks and via the internet. Why anyone would want to pretend we don't know how anaesthetics work when it is so clear we do is a mystery, but possibly reflects the limited grasp medical and veterinary homeopaths have of proper medicine.



Even if we didn’t know exactly how anaesthetics and other pharmaceuticals worked we do know they have recognised, analysable, physical content. We know exactly what they are. Their mode of action, even where not known precisely, will involve a number of pre-existing mechanisms, all firmly grounded in the known facts of neurology, physiology and biochemistry. All pharmaceuticals, including anaesthetics, follow predictible, rational patterns – if I dilute an anaesthetic it will have a reduced effect, if I use a stronger concentration it will have a more profound effect. And anaesthetics actually work. If I get the dose correct and use the proper delivery route my patients will go to sleep – every single time.

The rational basis of real drugs means if someone makes the claim that a particular pharmaceutical doesn’t work, or has unacceptible consequences that claim can be investigate using proven scientific principles and, depending on the results, the drug will either be withdrawn from use or have its safety profile enhanced. To take extreme examples of both – thalidomide was withdrawn from use in the middle of the 20th century after investigation showed it was causing an unacceptible level of deformities in new-born babies whereas claims the MMR vaccine caused autism in children were discovered to be without foundation once the research was carried out, consequently the MMR vaccine is now one of the safest, most widely researched drugs on the market.

Homeopathy on the other hand has no rational basis and no content other than sugar or water, its ‘mode of action’ is a pure fiction. Infact several pure fictions, depending on what you believe – quantum, nano-bubbles, spallation, cavitation, the life-force etc… You’ll find a different ‘mode of action’ at every website you care to visit on the subject. Unlike real drugs, homeopathy follows no rational or predictable pattern – behind the closed doors of the consulting room it is reported to have profound effects yet when looked at objectively those effects vanish to the margins of statistical significance. When homeopathy declines to perform when tested by science homeopaths, instead of upping the ante and doing better research, simply make excuses; the energy has been ‘antidoted’ (by pretty much any substance you care to mention), or it’s being tested by people who don’t ‘understand’, or it’s the ‘wrong type’ of homeopathy – not individualised, or isopathy – or we’re looking at the ‘wrong results’. Yet all those excuses go out of the window if the results look even vaguely like they support the idea homeopathy works. Homeopaths’ view of a well-conducted trial is one that proves, not tests homeopathy, and that's not how proper science works.

Finally, with homeopathy if you dilute it, it supposedly gets stronger, not weaker. And no theory of homeopathy’s ‘mode of action’ has ever managed to explain that one. Why homeopathy should get more quantum activity, nano-particles, energy signatures, micro-clusters or whatever the more dilute it is, remains a total mystery, even to the most imaginitive of those practitioners and multi-national corporations who profit by it.